Rotate the coordinate system to align an existing plane with Y'Z' plane

33 visualizaciones (últimos 30 días)
I have a plane z = (-47.407313)*x + (0.322175)*y + (-3.333979) and data points of a ball flight trajectory on it. Even though the best fit is known to be a parabola, since the plane in discussion doesn't align with any of the XY, YZ and ZX planes, it is infeasible to define an explicit relationship z = F(x,y) for obtaining such a curve using curve fitting. Now, my only idea is to rotate the coordinate system so that the plane is parallel to Y'Z' where I can apply (z')=a(y')^2+b(y')+c. After finding the best fit and sampling the points on the fit, I need to retract the coordinate system to get the actual coordinates. Even though the idea seems clear, the application in MATLAB doesn't and I'm hoping someone can guide me with the rotation.
I would be grateful if anyone can suggest an alternate, easier approach to get the 3D best fit equation without this hassle.
  3 comentarios
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH el 16 de Mayo de 2022
Editada: PASUNURU SAI VINEETH el 16 de Mayo de 2022
One of the answers helped me. After obtaining the curve fit and sampling, I transformed them back to the original coordinate system where I could apply equations of motion.
Btw, do you know of a way I can directly fit a 3D curve (not the surface or a spline along the surface that isn't smooth)? The process is straightforward for 2D and I couldn't do the 3D fit even after projecting all the points to the best fit plane (angled to the XY, YZ and ZX). I am looking to eliminate this hassle of plane projection and double transformation.
Matt J
Matt J el 16 de Mayo de 2022
You would need a parametric model for the 3D trajectory (x(t), y(t),z(t))

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Respuestas (3)

Torsten
Torsten el 15 de Mayo de 2022
Editada: Torsten el 15 de Mayo de 2022
But are you sure that the parabola in the YZ plane is not also rotated ?
  5 comentarios
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH el 16 de Mayo de 2022
Okay, I understand your point now. Yeah the parabola need not be aligned with the Z-axis. It somehow worked for this case but do you suggest a general formula ay^2+bz^2+cyz+dy+ez+f=0 when the direction of directrix is arbritary?
Torsten
Torsten el 16 de Mayo de 2022
If you have a 3d-model of the parabola of the form
(a*t^2+b*t+c;d*t^2+e*t+f;g*t^2+h*t+i)
you can directly fit the 9 parameters in question.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.


Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong el 16 de Mayo de 2022
Take a look at this thread and see if you can use it
  2 comentarios
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH el 16 de Mayo de 2022
Appreciate your response. The thread Torsten shared helped me.
Btw, do you know of a way I can directly fit a 3D curve (not the surface or a spline along the surface that isn't smooth)? The process is straightforward for 2D and I couldn't do the 3D fit even after projecting all the points to the best fit plane (angled to the XY, YZ and ZX). I am looking to eliminate this hassle of plane projection and double transformation.
Bruno Luong
Bruno Luong el 16 de Mayo de 2022
The answer I gave in the above thread shows to use SVD to fit a point clouds, the input point cloud can be a non degenerated curve (i.e. not a line) and not necessary a plane.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.


Matt J
Matt J el 16 de Mayo de 2022
Editada: Matt J el 16 de Mayo de 2022
If you didn't obtain your plane fit with planarFit() from,
then I suggest you do so. If you did use planarFit(), then the rotation is easy:
pfit=planarFit(xyz);
yz_prime = pfit.R(:,2:3)'*xyz;
However, once you've rotated the data this way, you still can't be sure in which direction gravity pulls (see also my comment above).
One solution would be to post-optimize the in-plane rotation of yz
theta=fminbnd(@(theta) postfun(theta,yz_prime), 0,pi);
[~,abc]=postfun(theta,yz_prime)
using the 1D objective function,
function [fval,abc]=postfun(theta,yz_prime)
R=makehgtform('zrotate',theta);
yz=R(1:2,1:2)*yz_prime;
[abc,S]=polyfit(yz(:,1),yz(:,2),2)
fval=S.normr;
end
  1 comentario
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH
PASUNURU SAI VINEETH el 17 de Mayo de 2022
Thank you. I have used Least Squares method for finding the coefficients of best fit plane. I will definitely try the method you've suggested.

Iniciar sesión para comentar.

Categorías

Más información sobre Get Started with Curve Fitting Toolbox en Help Center y File Exchange.

Productos


Versión

R2021b

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by